The Interactive Guide

Your transcript, essays, and activities list are all things you shaped, wrote, curated, or controlled. Your letters of recommendation are different. They’re one of the only places in your application where someone else gets to talk about you, in their own words, without you in the room.

You can tell colleges that you’re intellectually curious. Your teacher can describe the question you asked after class that somehow turned into a 20-minute conversation.

Your application tells colleges who you believe you are. Your recommendations give them someone else’s evidence.

Here’s the slightly strange part: you ultimately have no control over what that person writes.

But you have a lot more control over the circumstances that produce the letter than you probably realize.

And, long before recommendation season ever arrives, you decide whether you give them anything interesting to remember.

So no, you cannot write your own recommendation letter.

But you can make it a whole lot easier for someone else to write a great one.

Think of your teacher recommendations as the close-up view. Your teachers have actually watched you operate in an academic environment day after day. They can describe how you think, the kinds of questions you ask, how you contribute to discussions, what happens when something doesn’t come easily, how you respond to feedback, how you work with other students, and how you’ve changed over time. In other words, they can tell colleges what it’s actually like to have you in the classroom.

Your counselor recommendation is more of a wide-angle view. Your counselor can help colleges understand the larger context of your high school experience: your school and its academic environment, the rigor of the courses you’ve chosen, your academic trajectory, your involvement in the broader school community, and any circumstances or responsibilities that help explain the story your transcript alone can’t tell.

Both perspectives matter. Your teachers help colleges understand you as a student. Your counselor helps them understand the bigger picture around that student.

There is, however, one small complication: you get to choose your teacher recommenders. You generally do not get to choose your counselor.

At a small school, your counselor may have known you since freshman year and already have plenty to say. At a large public high school, your counselor may be responsible for hundreds of students and know you primarily as the person who needed a schedule change sophomore year.

That’s not a reflection on you or your counselor. It’s just math.

And it means that if your counselor doesn’t know you particularly well yet, you need to help them get to know you.

No, this does not mean suddenly appearing in their office every Tuesday with baked goods and an aggressively charming personality. It means using the opportunities you already have to build a real relationship. Meet with them when you have legitimate questions. Talk to them about what you’re considering for college and why. Make sure they know about significant accomplishments, responsibilities, challenges, or goals that might not be obvious from looking at your transcript.

And if your school gives you a counselor questionnaire or brag sheet, take it seriously. That may be one of your best opportunities to give your counselor the context they need to write something more meaningful than a summary of information colleges can already see elsewhere in your application.

Don’t wait until senior fall, introduce yourself for what feels like the first time, and then hope they somehow produce a deeply personal two-page tribute to your character.

Give them something to work with.

This is probably the most important decision you’ll make in the recommendation process, and it’s also the one students get wrong most often. Usually for the same reason: they choose the class where they earned the highest grade.

Colleges already know you got an A in AP Chemistry. It’s on your transcript. We do not need to dedicate an entire recommendation letter to confirming information they already have.

What colleges don’t know is what you were actually like in that chemistry class.

That’s the stuff we want from a recommendation letter.

So when you’re deciding whom to ask, the most important factor isn’t whether you earned your highest grade in their class. It’s how well that teacher actually knows you and whether they have specific things to say about you.

You could have spent an entire year quietly sitting in the third row, completing every assignment, acing every test, and interacting with your teacher primarily through an occasional “Have a good weekend!” Your teacher may think you’re wonderful. They may also sit down to write your letter and realize that, beyond your excellent academic performance, they don’t have much material.

Meanwhile, another teacher may have watched you struggle with genuinely difficult material, ask for help, completely rethink your approach, take intellectual risks, contribute something unusual to discussions, help the people around you, or become a dramatically more confident student over the course of the year.

Maybe you got an A in that class. Maybe you got a B+.

Because ultimately, the strongest recommendation letters don’t just pile on flattering adjectives. They give admissions officers specific moments and observations that help them understand what it’s actually like to teach you.

And yes, a perfect grade and a fantastic relationship can absolutely coexist. If you earned the A+ and your teacher could write a small biography about you? Fantastic. We love an easy decision.

But don’t confuse “I did really well in their class” with “they know me really well.”

Those are two very different things.

So, how do you know whether a teacher actually knows you well enough?

Let’s test it.

Still not sure whether the teacher you’re considering actually knows you well enough to write a great letter? Let’s find out.

Forget the grade for a minute. Instead, think about what this teacher has actually seen, heard, and experienced with you.

Could this teacher write a great letter about you?

Answered {{ answeredCount }} of 8 Reset / try another teacher

{{ q.num }}

{{ q.text }}

{{ q.detail }}

Yes No

It can help, but it is definitely not the most important thing.

If you’re applying for engineering and your physics teacher knows you extremely well, fantastic. If you’re interested in English and your AP Literature teacher can talk about the bizarre interpretation you defended for twenty minutes in class, the evolution of your writing, and the conversations you regularly continued after the bell rang, also fantastic.

A teacher in a subject related to your intended major can reinforce the academic interests you’re presenting elsewhere in your application. But major alignment should never come at the expense of getting an actually good letter.

Imagine you’re applying for computer science and choosing between two teachers.

Who has more to say about you?

Probably the history teacher.

Your application already tells colleges that you’re interested in computer science. It already tells them that you took AP Computer Science and earned an A+. We do not need to use an entire recommendation letter just to confirm information they can find elsewhere. What we do need is someone who can tell them something they couldn’t learn without that letter.

So yes, consider your intended major when choosing recommenders. If you have an excellent relationship with a teacher in a related subject, that can be a really nice fit.

But if you’re choosing between “relevant subject, barely knows me” and “less relevant subject, could write a small biography about me,” I’m taking the biography.

If you’re submitting two teacher recommendations, don’t choose each one in a vacuum. Think about what the two letters are likely to say about you together.

Suppose your AP Calculus teacher knows you incredibly well and can speak to your analytical thinking, persistence, and willingness to wrestle with difficult problems. Great. Now suppose your AP Physics teacher also knows you well...but would probably highlight your analytical thinking, persistence, and willingness to wrestle with difficult problems.

Those could both be excellent letters. But they may also be telling colleges essentially the same story twice.

Calculus + Physics Calculus + English

Now imagine that your other option is an AP English teacher who has seen a completely different side of you: your creativity, sense of humor, willingness to challenge an interpretation, ability to engage other students in discussion, or the way your writing changed over the course of the year.

Suddenly, the two letters are doing different jobs, and colleges are getting a much fuller picture of who you are.

This is one reason a STEM + humanities combination can work particularly well. Those teachers often see you using very different intellectual muscles. But subject area is only one way to create that balance. Maybe one teacher can speak to your intellectual curiosity while another has watched you become a leader in the classroom. Maybe one has seen you at your absolute academic best while another watched you struggle, regroup, and grow. Maybe one knows the serious, analytical version of you while another knows the version who makes everyone around them more comfortable speaking up.

That’s the kind of complementarity we’re looking for.

An important caveat

But please do not manufacture variety just for the sake of variety. If your two strongest recommenders both happen to teach STEM subjects, the humanities teacher who barely knows you does not magically become a better choice because they would make your recommendation portfolio look nicely balanced.

As always, relationship comes first. We’re looking for different perspectives among people who can actually write strong letters about you.

Generally, more recent is better. Colleges are trying to understand who you are now, not who you were when you wandered into freshman year four years ago.

That’s why junior-year teachers are often the sweet spot. They’ve taught you recently, they’ve had a full academic year to get to know you, and you can usually ask them before everyone disappears for summer. If a teacher has taught you more than once, even better. They may be able to speak not only to who you are now, but also to how much you’ve grown over time.

Senior-year teachers can absolutely work too, but the calendar can make things tricky if you’re applying early. If your first deadline is November 1 and your teacher met you for the first time in late August, you’re asking them to form a meaningful impression of you pretty quickly. They might be able to write a fantastic letter, especially if you’ve had them before or know them through another activity, but two months simply doesn’t give them a whole lot of material.

And what about a sophomore-year teacher? If that person knows you exceptionally well, taught you again later, advises one of your activities, or has maintained a meaningful relationship with you, don’t automatically rule them out just because another teacher is more recent.

Recent + Knows you well The ideal combination

What If I’m Reading This in September?

Ask in person whenever reasonably possible.

I know, I know. Sending an email is easier. Less awkward. No eye contact required. You can reread your message fourteen times, change “Hi” to “Hello” and back again, and then stare at the Send button for another five minutes.

But asking face-to-face gives you something email doesn’t: information.

Pay attention to how your teacher responds. Do they light up? Do they immediately tell you they’d be happy to? Do they start reminiscing about something you did in class or seem genuinely touched that you chose them? Great signs.

Or is there a four-second pause followed by: “Um...sure?”

That pause is information too.

If possible, find a good moment to ask rather than cornering your teacher while they’re sprinting to their next class, carrying six folders, and clearly trying to eat the granola bar that is apparently serving as lunch. You want them to have enough time to actually think about what you’re asking.

And when you ask, there is one very important word I want you to use.

Then stop talking.

I mean it. Stop. Talking.

You do not need to fill the silence, explain why you think they’re perfect, or launch into a five-minute presentation on your qualifications. Give them a second to think and let them answer honestly.

That word strong matters because it gives a teacher who likes you but doesn’t feel they know you well enough a graceful way to say so.

And as uncomfortable as that answer might feel in the moment, it is a gift.

You would much rather hear, “I really enjoyed having you in class, but I’m not sure I’m the person who can write the strongest letter for you,” than discover six months later that your recommendation essentially says:

Exhibit A  ·  the useless letter

“Laura was a student in my fourth-period class. She completed her assignments on time.”

Oof.

A teacher who tells you they aren’t the right person isn’t rejecting you. They’re giving you the opportunity to ask someone who can do a better job advocating for you.

So if someone hesitates, pay attention. And please don’t respond by trying to convince them that, actually, they know you much better than they apparently think they do.

You’re choosing someone to advocate for you when you aren’t in the room.

We want someone who is genuinely excited to do it.

Once a teacher says yes, your job isn’t done. In fact, this is where you can do a lot to help them write a stronger letter.

First, find out whether your high school has a specific recommendation questionnaire or brag sheet. Many schools do, and if yours does, take the time to fill it out thoughtfully and thoroughly.

This is not an assignment to knock out in twelve minutes during lunch while simultaneously eating a sandwich and texting your friend. Your teacher is eventually going to sit down in front of a blank document and try to capture you on a page. Give them something good to work with.

And here’s where students tend to go wrong:

Your brag sheet is not your résumé in paragraph form.

Your teacher does not need three paragraphs explaining that you’re President of Key Club, Treasurer of Student Council, a varsity soccer player, and a hospital volunteer. That information can certainly provide useful context, but your résumé can give them the highlight reel.

Your brag sheet should give them the stories.

Give them anecdotes, not adjectives.

Your teacher can remember those office-hour conversations. They can talk about the kinds of questions you were asking. They can connect that curiosity to the project you eventually pursued. Suddenly, instead of having to tell colleges you’re intellectually curious, they can show them.

That’s what we want.

As you complete your brag sheet, think back through the year and jog your teacher’s memory.

Basically, give your teacher the receipts.

And don’t limit yourself to what happened inside their classroom. Think about what your teacher doesn’t know about you, too.

Maybe they’ve noticed that you’re exceptionally patient with classmates, but they don’t know that you spend three evenings a week teaching younger dancers. Maybe they’ve watched you arrive at school exhausted but have no idea that you work a closing shift three nights a week. Maybe they know you love biology but don’t know that you spend Saturdays volunteering at an animal shelter.

Your teacher only sees one slice of your life. They are not secretly following you around after sixth period collecting material for your recommendation letter. Giving them a little more context can help them understand why you show up the way you do and connect qualities they’ve already observed in the classroom to the person you are outside of it.

That’s what a good brag sheet should do. You’re not telling your teacher what to say about you. You’re reminding them of the stories they already know and filling in enough of the background that they can tell those stories well.

Your teacher knows you in the context of their classroom, but there may be a whole lot about you they’ve never had a reason to know. Your résumé gives them a quick look at the bigger picture: what you do outside of class, where you’ve taken on leadership or responsibility, how you spend your time, and what interests or accomplishments might help them understand you more fully.

But your résumé and your brag sheet serve very different purposes.

Ideally, you give them both. Your résumé provides the context, while your brag sheet gives them the stories, details, and memories they can actually use to bring the letter to life.

Remember, you’re not trying to tell your teacher what to write. You’re trying to make sure they’re not sitting in front of a blank document trying to remember everything they know about you. Give them good material, and make their job easier.

Some colleges allow you to submit an optional recommendation in addition to the teacher letters they require. The existence of that option does not mean you need to use it.

Before adding another recommender, ask yourself one question: What can this person tell colleges about me that my other recommenders can’t?

A research mentor who has watched you work independently for a year might be able to speak to your curiosity and initiative in ways your classroom teachers can’t. An employer who has trusted you with real responsibility can show colleges what you’re like outside of school. A coach might have watched you lead through adversity, while a music instructor who has worked with you for years may be able to describe your discipline and growth over a much longer period of time.

Those are genuinely different perspectives. That’s what an additional recommendation should add.

What we do not need is another adult saying essentially the same nice things about you, particularly if the main appeal is that the adult happens to have an impressive title.

But prestige is not a substitute for specificity.

The supervisor who has watched you work every Saturday for two years can almost certainly tell colleges more about you than the Very Important Person who needs to be reminded how the two of you met.

And if a college explicitly says it does not want additional recommendations, believe them. Sending one anyway doesn’t demonstrate extra enthusiasm or give you a secret admissions advantage.

It demonstrates that you didn’t follow the instructions.

When you add recommenders through the Common App, you’ll encounter something called the FERPA Release Authorization and be asked whether you want to waive your right to review your recommendation letters.

In plain English, waiving your FERPA rights means you’re agreeing that you won’t ask to see the letters your recommenders submit on your behalf. That matters because colleges want to know that your teachers were able to write honestly and candidly, without wondering whether you would eventually be reading over their shoulders.

And yes, I understand the instinct to think, “But why would I voluntarily give up the right to see something being written about ME?” In this case, not knowing is kind of the point. The value of a recommendation comes from the fact that it’s an independent perspective on you, not another piece of the application you’ve reviewed, edited, or controlled.

If you’re confused about what you’re agreeing to when you reach this section, ask your school counselor before completing it. But assuming you understand the waiver and are comfortable proceeding, this is one box I want you to check without trying to outsmart the process.

Naviance, Scoir, Schoolinks, and Other School Systems

What If I’m Applying Through Multiple Platforms?

Teachers are busy, and even the most organized, well-intentioned ones can lose track of a deadline when they’re juggling classes, grading, and a stack of other recommendation letters. It is completely okay to follow up.

If your deadline is still several weeks away and the letter hasn’t been submitted, there’s no reason to panic. As you get closer, send a polite reminder. If the deadline is approaching and your portal still shows the recommendation as outstanding, it’s perfectly reasonable to check in again.

You are not being annoying by keeping track of an important piece of your application.

You will start becoming annoying if you’re sending daily reminders, demanding to know exactly when they’ll submit, sounding accusatory, unnecessarily deploying your parents as backup, or suddenly appearing 48 hours before the deadline in a full-blown state of emergency.

The goal is warm, appreciative, and organized. Remember, this person is doing you a favor, so your follow-up should sound like a grateful reminder, not a collections notice.

And ultimately, it’s your responsibility to make sure everything gets where it needs to go. Don’t assume a letter has been submitted just because you handed your teacher a brag sheet six weeks ago. Check your application portal, keep an eye on the status, and follow up when you need to.

At the end of the day, you cannot manufacture a great letter of recommendation.

You can’t hand a teacher the perfect brag sheet in September and magically create a relationship that wasn’t there.

The best recommendation letters are built long before they’re written.

They’re built in the questions you ask after class, the way you respond when something doesn’t come easily, the conversations you have during office hours, the energy you bring to a discussion, the way you treat your classmates, and all the tiny interactions that probably don’t feel particularly important while they’re happening.

Then, when recommendation season arrives, your job is to choose the people who actually noticed those things and give them everything they need to tell the story well.

The goal isn’t to find the teacher with the most impressive title, the class where you earned the highest grade, or the person you think will write the most glowing adjectives.

The goal is to ask someone who can sit down at their computer, see your name, and immediately think: